CONTAX CLUB Carl Zeiss 討論區

香港互聯網康泰時攝影會
現在的時間是 週三 20 11月 19 16:42:31

所有顯示的時間為 UTC + 8 小時




發表新文章 回覆主題  [ 10 篇文章 ] 
發表人 內容
文章發表於 : 週六 01 9月 07 18:13:16 
資深討論區會員

註冊時間: 週三 04 1月 06 22:55:14
文章: 3990
B&W Ilford HP5

圖檔

Slide Fujifilm Velvia 50

圖檔

Print Film Kodak Colourmax 400

圖檔

Digital Olympus E-1

圖檔

All photos taken on same spot same day same condition with C/Y 18mm f/4.

Film or Digital really a matter or choice......


回頂端
 個人資料  
 
 文章主題 :
文章發表於 : 週日 02 9月 07 00:03:41 
討論區新手

註冊時間: 週三 18 5月 05 11:44:42
文章: 32
For this post, I personally vote for B&W ...

For other situations, it depends ...

Coz no media can be the best media in every single situation ...


回頂端
 個人資料  
 
 文章主題 :
文章發表於 : 週日 02 9月 07 03:10:15 
討論區管理員

註冊時間: 週四 27 11月 03 02:15:48
文章: 3194
來自: Moon Base Alpha
Well both the slide and the Neg shown quite inaccurate color ( as I recall, I might be wrong though ) but then since its not the original ( they are both digital scan of the film ) I can give them benefit of the doubt.

No doubt in these days of so much technical advance, the good old B&W Neg still give the most defining details and image. of course you can't have color with it though ...

_________________
圖檔 圖檔 圖檔


回頂端
 個人資料  
 
 文章主題 :
文章發表於 : 週日 02 9月 07 21:57:51 
CONTAX CLUB 會員
CONTAX CLUB 會員

註冊時間: 週五 06 8月 04 02:36:46
文章: 5314
來自: 那星
I agree with FR that the colors are not accurate....

Regarding the choice, well, as it is the San Francisco Golden Gate Bridge and its selling point is her reddish color, so I will choose the color slide. :wink:

_________________
Please visit my photo gallery and your comments are always welcome!
I will add photos to it from time to time. Thank you!
http://www.flickr.com/people/yualbert
圖檔


回頂端
 個人資料  
 
 文章主題 :
文章發表於 : 週日 02 9月 07 22:58:25 
資深討論區會員

註冊時間: 週三 04 1月 06 22:55:14
文章: 3990
哈哈!呢到的大大真係心水清。

沒錯,在正片看色水係正常好多。

但係$50一筒Slide沖加CD都唔可能Expect36張都Perfect Scan。
Film 那張都係$36/roll 沖加CD
如果自己有Scanner同時間應該可以Scan得好些。

Digital來講我都唔係好識"汁",應該仲可以好些。


回頂端
 個人資料  
 
 文章主題 :
文章發表於 : 週一 03 9月 07 01:31:51 
討論區管理員

註冊時間: 週四 27 11月 03 02:15:48
文章: 3194
來自: Moon Base Alpha
Well, actually its kind of easy to tell, Look at that White Vans that park along the building. How white it is pretty much signal how well the color shows. ( Do note that White van are almost never White, but generally kind of little bit of yellow in reality )

All photo shown the white a little off-white, so using that as a point for Basis. ONE can do correction easily. But again look at the foreground seashore and the boulders. The Slide shown definite Blue-Green color cast typical of the Velvia, which is why the bridge's Orange-Red shown muddy and the water / sky so intense in color, unfortunately all those are probably not how reality look like. Also the Concrete pylon of the bridge is way off

The ho-hum Kodak Neg film actually is pretty neutral and correct in hue, but its either the scan ( density of neg affect ) or the exposure. the saturation is not correct.

The digital is actually the best among the 3 in term of data and accuracy of data that is. The White balance is probably not correct but in this case it cannot be help, becasue typical SF Sunny day could play havoc in such case ( it is typically much higher than the 5500K and AWB would probably be foiled by too much sky in this shoot )

I would guess on the real slide and neg film, the definition would be much higher, but unless one invest in time and effort to do a high quality scan. A DSLR in these cases prove better for making a digital image of such nature.

_________________
圖檔 圖檔 圖檔


回頂端
 個人資料  
 
 文章主題 :
文章發表於 : 週一 03 9月 07 10:58:16 
資深討論區會員

註冊時間: 週三 04 1月 06 22:55:14
文章: 3990
FR 寫:
Well, actually its kind of easy to tell, Look at that White Vans that park along the building. How white it is pretty much signal how well the color shows. ( Do note that White van are almost never White, but generally kind of little bit of yellow in reality )

All photo shown the white a little off-white, so using that as a point for Basis. ONE can do correction easily. But again look at the foreground seashore and the boulders. The Slide shown definite Blue-Green color cast typical of the Velvia, which is why the bridge's Orange-Red shown muddy and the water / sky so intense in color, unfortunately all those are probably not how reality look like. Also the Concrete pylon of the bridge is way off

The ho-hum Kodak Neg film actually is pretty neutral and correct in hue, but its either the scan ( density of neg affect ) or the exposure. the saturation is not correct.

The digital is actually the best among the 3 in term of data and accuracy of data that is. The White balance is probably not correct but in this case it cannot be help, becasue typical SF Sunny day could play havoc in such case ( it is typically much higher than the 5500K and AWB would probably be foiled by too much sky in this shoot )

I would guess on the real slide and neg film, the definition would be much higher, but unless one invest in time and effort to do a high quality scan. A DSLR in these cases prove better for making a digital image of such nature.


FR大大又"蝨"錢入我袋,正! :D
謝謝!


回頂端
 個人資料  
 
 文章主題 :
文章發表於 : 週一 03 9月 07 13:31:43 
CONTAX CLUB 會員
CONTAX CLUB 會員

註冊時間: 週六 15 11月 03 13:50:00
文章: 458
來自: Hong Kong
G2 Lover兄,

有無D T-Max 既B&W相睇呀 :?: :?: :?:

_________________
愛吃小菜, 更愛中菜, 想吃大菜 .......
www.digiback.net


回頂端
 個人資料  
 
 文章主題 :
文章發表於 : 週一 03 9月 07 22:21:43 
資深討論區會員

註冊時間: 週三 04 1月 06 22:55:14
文章: 3990
Victor Sze 寫:
G2 Lover兄,

有無D T-Max 既B&W相睇呀 :?: :?: :?:


Oh here you go:

Kodak B&W

http://www.fotop.net/Turtle/kodakbandwplan

Ilford B&W

http://www.fotop.net/Turtle/ilford


China B&W

http://www.fotop.net/Turtle/luckybandwfilm


回頂端
 個人資料  
 
 文章主題 :
文章發表於 : 週一 03 9月 07 23:29:12 
CONTAX CLUB 會員
CONTAX CLUB 會員

註冊時間: 週六 15 11月 03 13:50:00
文章: 458
來自: Hong Kong
G2 Lover 寫:
Victor Sze 寫:
G2 Lover兄,

有無D T-Max 既B&W相睇呀 :?: :?: :?:


Oh here you go:

Kodak B&W

http://www.fotop.net/Turtle/kodakbandwplan

Ilford B&W

http://www.fotop.net/Turtle/ilford


China B&W

http://www.fotop.net/Turtle/luckybandwfilm


嘩............................正呀 !!!!!

_________________
愛吃小菜, 更愛中菜, 想吃大菜 .......
www.digiback.net


回頂端
 個人資料  
 
顯示文章 :  排序  
發表新文章 回覆主題  [ 10 篇文章 ] 

所有顯示的時間為 UTC + 8 小時


誰在線上

正在瀏覽這個版面的使用者:沒有註冊會員 和 1 位訪客


不能 在這個版面發表主題
不能 在這個版面回覆主題
不能 在這個版面編輯您的文章
不能 在這個版面刪除您的文章

搜尋:
前往 :  
cron
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
正體中文語系由 竹貓星球 維護製作